Why Depression is not a "New, Trendy Illness"

By Lauren Cooke

My name is Lauren and I have Clinical Depression. I have for years and years, ever since the hormones of my teenage years kicked in and suddenly the world got very hard to handle. Whilst still being a happy funny girl on top of everything, underneath I was battling with a nightmare, with an undercurrent of darkness that was ruining my enjoyment of everything, and making me want to give up on life.

I regularly thought about committing suicide, and developed the worrying mentality that I wasn’t “brave” enough to kill myself. I am OK now thanks to some lovely depression-beating drugs, but for a while there it was much more touch and go than anyone wanted to admit.

Because I understand depression and know how bad it can be, I was utterly appalled by the Janice Street-Porter article that turned up in this week’s Daily Mail. I know that she is a complete plank anyway, and the DM isn’t exactly the most trusted newspaper in the world, but even so I got more shocked and indignant than normal when I read it. 

This article, wonderfully titled “Depression? It’s just the new trendy illness!”, is a rambling and unresearched diatribe explaining in JSPs wonderful dulcet tones about the “relatively new” illness that is depression, and the fact that people are suffering from it as part of trend-following peer-pressure rather than anything even remotely medical.

We had come so far with mental illness. Charities like Mind UK had managed to make more and more people understand that mental illness isn’t something to be shunned and hidden, but something that happens to millions of people throughout the UK, and is a condition that needs to be taken seriously. 

With all of the steps forward in accurate and intelligent treatment of illnesses such as depression, schizophrenia and other such examples, you would think that things had actually changed. Well, thanks to philistines like Janice waxing lyrical to a pack of gossip hungry Daily Mail readers, it seems like that change hasn’t actually happened. After all, how is progress meant to be made with public figures holding us back – and even when those in the public eye who have been brave enough to admit to depression do so, they are being “named and shamed” as spoiled brats.

Thankfully Janice Street-Porter’s assertions that only the rich get depression, that it doesn’t exist, that there is no stigma attached to mental illness and that stress and depression are one and the same (you know, like cancer and a heart problem are one and the same) haven’t gone unnoticed. Mind has written a beautifully worded and intelligence response, and bloggers have been quick to attack the shallow depth of knowledge and complete lack of research.

As one of so many people who have suffered from depression, I seek an apology in The Mail (yeah, right, like that will happen…) – and I hope that all the people who read it have treated it like what it is – an abusive and uneducated tirade from a confused and naïve woman.

A few of the facts

- Depression in one form or other has been around since the middle ages – it is just the name that is relatively “new” – and the massive growth in numbers can be attributed to societal changes and the availability of treatment

- Whilst much depression is recovered from independently, many people are rendered unable to carry on with life, demonstrating the severity of the disease

- Depression can be treated using counselling/therapy options, or medically. Different types of depression require different approaches.

Further Reading

If you want to read a bit more about depression and understand it from a sufferer’s point of view, then my personal favourites are:

The Bell Jar, by Sylvia Plath

The Yellow Wallpaper, by Charlotte Perkins Gilman

Shoot the Damn Dog, by Sally Brampton

POSTED IN: LIFE
Fri, 21 May 2010 17:00 (GMT+00)
3 Responses
1.

Well said, and thank you for sharing your experience. I'm glad you're OK these days.

As you've mentioned, what was particularly telling about JSP's ill-informed tirade was how often she switched between 'stress' and 'depression', failing to understand the difference in terminology, and paying brief, unthinking lip service to the existence of 'clinical depression' (what, if you don't put clinical in front it's not real?) and post-natal depression as if only these types really exist.

Clearly what JSP actually wanted to complain about was a few people she suspected of being bogged down with first world problems, calling it stress and getting signed off work. What she ended up doing was tackling a medical subject she hasn't a hope in hell of understand (and, if she's really lucky, experiencing).

A friend of mine recently pulled out the same excuse - that, coming from a poor background she knew women who'd suffered feelings we'd call depression but they were too busy trying to feed their families to get treated, it's a first world imaginary problem etc etc. Another friend with the same background begged to differ, pointing out that many people suffer without treatment because of exactly that kind of attitude, and that she'd watched similarly poor relatives who had been left to get on with it and 'feed their families', and ended up committing suicide due to the lack of intervention. Not being diagnosed, treated or offered help is not the same as it not existing; JSP's increasingly patronising assertions that poor women 'cope admirably' made me cringe. Being left to suffer is not the same as coping.

Alex
Sun, 23-May-2010 18:26 GMT
2.

"Depression is normal to appear" You don't like a whole lot of people has well as some doctors who don't understand depression. Depression is caused by a lack of Serotonin just like a diabetic who doesn't who doesn't have he ability to produce its' own insullin. Pro Cleanse Gold

Gabriel Murphy
Mon, 02-Aug-2010 12:44 GMT
3.

I think that the situation with depression became very alarming. Statistics show that each year about 15 million adult Americans suffer from clinical depression. That is 8% of American population of age 18 and over. About 3% or 6 million Americans suffer from manic depression or bipolar depression each year. The population affected by depression is increasing each year. Irena from cheap web hosting

Irena
Sat, 26-Feb-2011 19:31 GMT

Add Comment

Note: Your email address will be verified but will never be published on the site.

If you are a registered user, please Sign In.




The opinions expressed by the author and commenters are their own and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of BitchBuzz or any employer or organisation. The aforementioned are not responsible for the accuracy of content published.

social feed

@BitchBuzz: The [Digital] Revolution Will Be Gendered - from @katelaity on BitchBuzz Tech http://t.co/5bkxZo0x
09 Feb @ 10:46 GMT

search



buzz we love

Bitchin' Lifestyle
Vikki Chowney
Bangs and a Bun
Vintage Patisserie
Pop Justice
The Other Woman
Pamflet
Gala Darling
Red Velvet
Shape What's to Come
Bird's Eye View
Gala Darling
Bake & Destroy
Kris Atomic
Mark Johns
Garfunkel & Oates
India Knight
Kate Nash
Erin Gibson
Sarah Lacy
Vegansaurus
The Boss of You
Meantime Brewery
Make and Do with Perri