In Defense of the Un-Mother: No Kids For Me!

By Liz Abinante

It is downright unacceptable to be a woman in America and not want children. I know this because every time I voice my dislike of children or my lack of desire to have them, I’m corrected. Perfect strangers tell me "you'll change your mind someday" and friends say "things will change when you find the right man". But would it really be so bad if things didn't change and I never wanted children?

Kids aren't that bad - really. There are quite a few children out there that I really like being around. But the majority of them behave badly and make loud noises in inappropriate public spaces.

If I say that, I'm told "oh things are different when you have your own children, those things don't bother you."

As if the only thing preventing me from reproducing thisverysecond was the fear that my child would be comparable to demonic spawn - or that I'd be a terrible parent like most young Americans. If it was that simple, I could delude myself into believing otherwise.

Doesn't that remind you of the scene in Sex and the City where Charlotte and Trey tell themselves “our kids will be different”, and Carrie narrates that is the lie every parent has to tell themselves?

But I'm not delusional, nor do I think I'd hate my own children.

If I say that I have better things to do with my life than raise another human being, I'm looked at with shock and terror. As if there is nothing worse than not wanting to devote your entire life (and a good chunk of your income) to carting children to and fro until they can take care of themselves.

If I say that I would rather adopt, people actually try to talk me into having my own kids. I think it takes a lot more gumption to adopt and raise a child you didn't give birth to than one that shot out of your vagina. People actually ask “why would you adopt if you can have your own?” They also say “well, you'll always want one of your own children, even if you adopt.”

Do I really need to tally all of the altruistic reasons to adopt? Perhaps my desire to actually help and raise a child without a family is greater than my selfish need to see a little mini me running around the world. And as far as biology is concerned, an adopted child is my child. Period. Genetics be damned.

Which brings me to my next logical reason for not wanting to breed: my family is a genetic disaster. Diabetes and all types of cancer on both sides, not to mention the fact that I only have one ovary. Is it so wrong of me to not want to bestow these genetic abnormalities on an unsuspecting child?

If I say that I believe children should have a stay-at-home parent for the first five years and I don't want to be that parent, people scoff. They say “what, do you really expect someone to want to be a stay-at-home dad?” Yes actually, I do. I think we let men believe they can't be good caretakers, and force women to think they're the only ones who can.

Not enough for you? I've got a few more reasons I could bounce your way...

But if you're not convinced by now that there’s nothing wrong with not wanting children, I'll never be able to make you believe that.

It bothers me that people question my reasoning behind not having children. It bothers me that people think I'm going to change my mind. But even more so, it bothers me that when people say they want to have children, nobody questions them.

Why is my choice constantly questioned? Wanting to have children was more complicated than not wanting to. So why aren't people questioning the choice to have children?

It should be a well thought out and planned thing (of course, accidents do happen). If you know you want children, you should organize all of the variables: financials, emotions, jobs, day care, insurance, everything. There should be more to wanting children than the burning desire to hold something you created in your hands or that you've always wanted to be a parent.

What I want to know is if those people who want children ever honestly looked at their lives and thought about not having children. I've thought about it, and still, no matter my response, I'm questioned.

Why is not wanting children so questionable and wanting them so acceptable?

Image from Getty.

POSTED IN: LIFE
Fri, 20 Feb 2009 18:00 (GMT+00)
4 Responses
1.

I used to get irritated by posts like these because of things like this: "but the majority of them behave badly and make loud noises in inappropriate public spaces." cos I simply don't think that's true - and I'm not a mother either. Plus I reserve my irritation for the parents (as you mention too), not the kids.

But then I began to realise that that kind of frustration is inevitable when you're constantly being barraged with questions and lofty commentary over your personal choices; I think I'd be ready to scream if I were being asked to justify a life decision that has nothing to do with anyone else all the time.

I think people HAVE started to question people who want to have children, though. I've said I'd like kids and already people have started up the whole 'what about the environment' question (which is fair enough, but also a bit of a red herring if you consider our actual impact on the world vs, say, China's). And I know plenty of women who don't want to have kids. Only one has changed her mind; the others are as quietly certain as ever. So when I talk about wanting kids to them (which is not that often, cos why would anyone care?) I get an expression of quiet horror. Which bugs me because I feel that as long as I'm a good parent and China is creating two new power stations a week, my decision ought not to effect them that much - I won't be asking them to babysit or listen to endless horror stories about mastitis.

Maybe the question isn't "why is not wanting children so questionable and wanting them so acceptable?" but "why can't everyone stay the hell out of everyone else's business when it doesn't concern them?"

Really interesting article - great to read.

Alex
Sun, 22-Feb-2009 11:36 GMT
2.

Liz, thankyou so much for this article. I'm thinking about the very same thing a great deal lately - everybody I know seems to be having babies, but I've never particularly wanted to have children myself. When I mentioned at work a few weeks ago that I don't want kids, the other girls in the office looked at me in horror like I'd casually mentioned that I wanted to chuck a bag o' kittens into a river. There should be more widespread acceptance of the choice of adults who decide that they don't want children of their own. Notions of family are so wide-ranging these days, why can't the notion of 'family' take in (for example) the 'urban family' of several adults living together, or of a couple living together without children? Thanks again for writing this. x

Sarah
Mon, 23-Feb-2009 13:11 GMT
3.

I thought maybe a baby maker might make a beneficial commenter.

I was 23 when I had my first kid. Two and a half years later, I gave birth to my second and last kid. And to this day, I'm still not sure I'm cut out to be a mom. My girls are now 7 and 4 and I love them dearly. I couldn't imagine my life without them. But I never planned to have children. Hell, I wasn't even sure I ever wanted to get married. I'm extremely selfish with my time, my energy, my body, and having two kids and a husband peel a lot of that away.

I should also say that I don't like kids. Sure, I like my two kids, but anyone else's kids drive completely batshit crazy. They make me extremely uncomfortable. So, yeah, there is some truth in the whole "Oh, you'll feel different about your children." You will. That doesn't mean you should be popping babies out. Just because a woman isn't annoyed by her own children doesn't mean she should be a mom.

I'm certain I fail at being a good mom on a daily basis. I don't watch my language around my children. I've been known to smoke in front of them. They listen to my music, watch my television shows, and understand my politics. I don't want them to be delusional or sheltered. So rather than be concerned with raising the perfect, well-behaved child, I focus on raising girls who can hold their own and have their own opinions and goals. The world has enough submissive, stupid women. I don't want my children to add to that population.

Now, if I had it all to do again, I don't know if I'd choose to have them. But I can't make that choice. So I love them now, teach them the things I think they need to know in order to not suck in this world, and practice a strict birth control regiment.

Having kids is a big job, but it isn't the only job. Fuck those who think it's a woman's destiny. If they like having babies so much, let 'em have at it.

Natalie
Tue, 24-Feb-2009 13:50 GMT
4.

Thanks for the well-written article. Neither my husband or I wants kids at all right now, but we're young and we realize that might change, so we're open to the idea of adoption. When I say this out loud it's as if I have just killed a puppy with my bare hands. It's a personal choice that makes sense to us! Please stop making me feel unhuman!

evy
Fri, 27-Feb-2009 20:31 GMT

Add Comment

Note: Your email address will be verified but will never be published on the site.

If you are a registered user, please Sign In.




The opinions expressed by the author and commenters are their own and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of BitchBuzz or any employer or organisation. The aforementioned are not responsible for the accuracy of content published.